Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay.
Worldwide
In the News

Is the oil industry cannibalising itself in geoscience recruitment?

Despite the drop in the number of students embarking on a geoscience degree, those who manage to graduate are often looking for work for a long time. What’s going on?

During his opening address to the IMAGE conference delegates in August this year, AAPG’s President John Casiano told the students in the room that this was the best time to join the industry, given the range of subsurface energy and storage roles that were to be filled. But is that really true?

“We advertised two graduate positions, and got around 400 applications,” someone told me at the same event. This was in Norway, the country where the number of students choosing geosciences as a degree has plummeted. Yet, despite this decline, there are still many out there who are seemingly desperate to join the industry.

This example does not stand in isolation. I met a student in the USA who was very candid about the lack of job opportunities. “I am told that I need to do internships,” he said. “But when I finally secure one, there is still absolutely no guarantee that there is a job waiting for me at the end. And the same is true when I do a second internship.” Some people told him that he needs to do a PhD as well. “But what will the job market look like in three years?” he asked rhetorically. He then went on to say that out of 12 students who recently graduated from his university, only one found a position in oil and gas. It just shows the very sorry state of recruitment with the majors.

Of course, there are exceptions. But I feel it’s very much like a lottery. A geologist who works for a major in Houston told me that during the years he has been there, he had not seen any graduates start in his department. So, it’s not only the students who see this lack of recruitment; people from within the companies are aware of it too.

The combination of no new graduate recruits, an ageing workforce, and redundancy rounds can have a detrimental effect on the number of geoscientists working in the energy industry. A short conversation with a business development manager of a service company is probably a testament to that. He told me that they are increasingly selling to engineers rather than geologists.

The increasing absence of operator stands on exhibition floors may also be a sign that there is hardly any recruitment going on. At this year’s IMAGE conference, there was not a single operator with a prominent stand. The service sector has completely taken over. It’s not to say that operators were always there for recruitment alone, but doesn’t it make more sense to exhibit and show yourself when you are looking for new talent to join?

Maybe graduates are not being hired, but that doesn’t mean that there is a complete hiring stop. As another geologist told me, there may even be an uptick in recruitment with some majors on the back of the increased interest in exploration. The “problem” is that the roles that are being filled are mostly going to those who have previous experience. And there are many of them around, given the numerous rounds of layoffs we have seen recent years.

It is this hiring of experienced people and leaving the graduates browsing the job market that creates a dangerous cycle. As another geoscientist told me: “It is the specialist jobs that we see a demand for now, biostratigraphers for instance. If someone with those skills is poached, where do we find a replacement? Because who graduates from a university with a biostratigraphy major these days?” This is where the title of the article comes from; there is a level of job cannibalisation happening that seems unsustainable in the long run.

Another indication that the majors are losing their internal specialists is yet another conversation I had. Someone who is part of a research consortium told me that one of the majors is now interested in potentially joining the consortium, after many years of showing no interest at all. This is yet another sign that the internal specialists within the company have moved on, which in turn results in more of a need to join a research consortium dedicated to a niche aspect of reservoir geology.

And what about those who are currently in one of those sought-after jobs? I spoke to various people about this, who all worked for the majors, and no one was very upbeat about the daily realities of their jobs. In other words, these people are basically keeping their heads down while awaiting the next redundancy round. Because that is probably the thing that is the most certain; there will soon be another request to apply internally for a new role. “Job security does not exist anymore,” someone said. People literally feel the threat of AI as well, with some of the majors being quite outspoken about this. Outsourcing of geoscience is another thing you don’t often hear about – granted, it leads to job opportunities elsewhere. 

Taking all this together, I am sometimes a little confused as to how it is possible that the world keeps on pumping 100 MMbbl of oil where the community of geoscientists making that happen seems to be in long-term decline. Of course, I have gradually learnt that geoscience is very much a niche sport even in the best of times, but let’s not forget that it is ultimately the geoscience discipline that is responsible for finding new fields, as well as supporting the drilling of appraisal and development wells. It looks as if the industry is not only cannibalising its people, but it is also cannibalising its reserves.

So, coming back to John Casiano’s statement during the IMAGE opening address; based on the conversations I’ve had recently, I still don’t see a real pickup in opportunities for graduates – to the extent that I’m truly interested in how this dynamic will unfold in the years to come. The concern voiced by so many industry leaders around the drop in students embarking on a geoscience degree may well be trumped by the lack of hiring from within their own ranks.

Previous article
A tale of a cave or how much in-place volume you might be missing

Related Articles